Share
Not every lead converts right away – and that’s okay.
Sometimes, promising opportunities go dark. Emails go unanswered, proposals sit untouched, and what once felt like a sure thing suddenly… chills.
But just because a lead goes cold doesn’t mean it’s gone forever.
Here’s how to re-engage those prospects, reignite their interest, and turn silence into sales with five proven strategies that work – especially when paired with the right tools and timing.
Table of Contents
1. Should I follow up with cold leads? (Short answer: Yes)
It might feel awkward, but following up is essential. A cold lead simply means they weren’t ready – not that they’ll never be. People get busy, priorities shift, and inboxes overflow. A well-timed follow-up gives you another chance to offer value and move the conversation forward.
Pro tip: Don’t just send “checking in” emails. Instead, follow up with new context – a relevant update, case study, or offer.
Related: What is a sales pipeline?
2. What are the best ways to reheat cold leads?
Here are five tried-and-true strategies:
1. Send a personalized, high-value message
Skip the generic follow-up. Instead, reference their specific pain points or project timeline and offer something new – like a fresh idea, relevant blog post, or a refreshed proposal.
“Thought of you when we rolled out this new feature – I think it could solve [insert specific problem] we discussed.”
2. Create urgency with a time-sensitive offer
Sometimes, a little incentive is all it takes to get things moving. Consider offering a limited-time discount, added service, or expedited timeline – but only if it makes sense for your business.
“We’ve got 3 slots left this quarter – wanted to give you early access before our calendar fills up.”
3. Leverage social proof
Share recent wins, testimonials, or stats that build trust. Cold leads might still be on the fence, so showing momentum and happy clients can nudge them closer to yes.
“Just wrapped a similar project with [Client Name] – would love to get yours rolling, too.”
Explore: What is a business proposal?
4. Update and re-send the original proposal
If your lead ghosted after receiving your proposal, it may be time for a refresh. Update pricing, reposition the offer, or add a new deliverable to better match their current goals. Then re-send it with a thoughtful message.
“Noticed we hadn’t finalized this – I’ve updated the scope to better align with what you mentioned about Q4 goals.”
With Proposaly, you can track when they re-open the link, where they spend the most time, and if they’re circling back – before they even reply.
5. Know when to let go – and go out with value
If you’ve followed up 3–4 times with no response, it might be time to close the loop – gracefully. A “breakup email” can trigger a response, even if just for closure.
“Totally understand if the timing’s not right. If anything changes down the line, here’s a quick link to the proposal with updated terms.”
This shows respect, keeps the door open, and gives them one last chance to act.
3. How long should I wait before following up?
It depends on your sales cycle, but a good rule of thumb is:
- First follow-up: 2–3 days after sending the proposal
- Second follow-up: 5–7 days after the first
- Third follow-up: 1–2 weeks later with new value
- Final attempt: A “last call” or offer expiration notice
Consistency matters. But so does tone – always aim to help, not hassle.
4. What tools help reheat cold leads faster?
A smart follow-up is only as strong as the system behind it.
Use:
- A CRM to track lead status and activity
- A proposal platform (like Proposaly) to send interactive proposals with e-signatures and analytics
- Email tools with open tracking
- LinkedIn or social media touchpoints for warmer re-engagement
With Proposaly, you can actually see when a cold lead starts warming back up – real-time viewing notifications make it easy to strike when interest sparks again.
Related: What is an e-signature?
5. What should I avoid when following up?
- Don’t guilt-trip your lead
- Don’t send “just bumping this up” emails repeatedly
- Don’t over-email – it erodes trust
- Don’t change your tone dramatically (stay consistent and professional)
Instead, always lead with value, respect their time, and make it easy for them to re-engage on their own terms.
Final thoughts
Cold leads aren’t dead – they’re just dormant. With the right approach, a little persistence, and the right tools, you can bring those opportunities back to life and turn “not now” into “let’s go.”
And if your proposals are still PDFs with zero visibility, you’re flying blind. Try Proposaly to send interactive, trackable proposals that help you follow up smarter – and close faster.
🔗 Start your free trial today at Proposaly.io and take control of your pipeline.
Trending Articles
Get exclusive CMO tips that I only share with email subscribers.
Don't forget to share this article!
PPC Marketing Expert?
Get things done with Adcore Marketing Cloud.
5 essential PPC tools under one roof.
Back to top